26 Comments
User's avatar
Coleman Ridge's avatar

Yes, and I don't want to be merely supportive, I want to critique, analyze, test, and consider, but without suppressing other people or making them angry or sad. If your first impulse when anyone says anything is to turn it upside down and try to take it apart, you need velvet gloves. "Yes and" is just such a pair of gloves.

Expand full comment
C. S. E. Cooney's avatar

Oh, Ellen! It is so exciting to read about how well--and how MERRILY--your revisions are going!

Expand full comment
Ellen Kushner's avatar

couldn't do it without you, love!

Expand full comment
C. S. E. Cooney's avatar

I love this rule, in theatre and games and life. I hope to do more of it myself, and surround myself with people who do.

Expand full comment
Ellen Kushner's avatar

It's such an interesting thought experiment! Sometimes when I'm writing - or even speaking - I play with what changing the word BUT to an AND will do to a sentence. It tends to be pretty nuanced - but there is a definite trajectory over the weeks.

Expand full comment
Jocelyn B's avatar

Regarding the first photo, if I had a retreat like that, I’d write, too! (Of course it would be “dreadful,” but I wouldn’t care!

Expand full comment
Rook R M McNamara's avatar

"Dad, I love you, and you're causing me grief." (I know you'll know why I chose this sentence)

Expand full comment
Ellen Kushner's avatar

I do. And it's perfect.

Expand full comment
Suzette Ciancio's avatar

Yes, and Brava! 💙

Expand full comment
Tony Mills's avatar

Good to read you again. Keep up the good work. Love your hair!

Expand full comment
Ellen Kushner's avatar

Thank you!

Expand full comment
Jocelyn B's avatar

It’s quite nice hair; also, as selfies go, it’s excellent.

Expand full comment
Ellen Kushner's avatar

You are kind!

Expand full comment
ellen klages's avatar

When I was around 11, my yeah-buts (also pronouced Yebbuts by my family) were so frequent that my fathet made a house rule: No Yebbuts after 6:00 pm.

(This was, not coincidentally, the time that he arrived home from work.)

Expand full comment
Ellen Kushner's avatar

Ha! It must have been in the air!

And, yeah: I should have spelled it "Yebbut"

Expand full comment
ellen klages's avatar

I guess it’s a known Young Ellen trait…

Expand full comment
Ellen Kushner's avatar

Clearly.

Expand full comment
Stace Dumoski's avatar

I sent one of those "oh my god, this is so boring" texts to my writing group just yesterday. It's very reassuring to hear this is not just something unpublished writers are plagued with.

Expand full comment
Ellen Kushner's avatar

I'm glad you have a group you feel you can be angsty at!

Everyone needs one.

Expand full comment
Stace Dumoski's avatar

Writing groups are essential!

Expand full comment
Esther Wheeler's avatar

Well yes, I would like to hear as much about the process as you want to share. Certainly some of why I'm here!

Expand full comment
Ellen Kushner's avatar

Thanks - good to know!

Expand full comment
Gregory Frost's avatar

I've always thought that "Mr. Earbrass" is the best depiction of the inner life of the writer anyone has captured.

Expand full comment
Ellen Kushner's avatar

Without a doubt.

Expand full comment
VirginiaM's avatar

I think you've hit on something with notes 5 and 6 here: that incoming repellent personification of a lego under one's foot IS evil AND lies to create a different reality.

400 years ago, In The Times Of LiveJournal, Yea, the tagline of mine (grabbed from a meme, probably) was "making new internets to push the bad internets down."

Ellen! I'm going to sit down and have a think (with pens in different colors, of course) about this. Clearly we need to make new realities to push the bad realities down.

Expand full comment
Ellen Kushner's avatar

Colored pens will definitely help!

Expand full comment